Mars (Marine Accident Reporting Scheme) Report is one of the regular sections of SWZ Maritime. The reports are also published online, as they may prevent other accidents from happening.

Mars Reports cover all kinds of maritime incidents such as (near) collisions and groundings, accidents with tools, falling objects injuring crew and accidents with rescue boats. You can find the latest reports below.

Pallet Snagged – Used Parts Gone: Mars 201455

The chief officer instructed the deck staff to transfer 22 used P/V valves from the top of the midship store to the main deck. The deck crew proceeded to pick up the pallet containing all 22 used P/V valves using the midship crane. While swinging the boom of the crane, the pallet snagged on the hose rail. As a result, the pallet was damaged and all 22 P/V valves were lost into the sea.

Lessons Learned

  • Both competent supervision and adequate planning are necessary to assist in safe outcomes. This was all the more necessary in this case given the lack of experience of the crew who were actually undertaking the task.
  • A Job Hazard Analysis was not consulted nor discussed with the staff prior to undertaking the task.
  • Company Safety Management procedures were not followed.
  • The practice of transferring all 22 units at one lift was flawed.

CO2 Labelling Mix-up: Mars 201456

During fire safety equipment verifications, the fixed CO2 cargo hold line identified as number five hold was tested by blowing compressed air into the system line. Despite this, no air passed through to the other end located at the forward and aft hatch coaming of number five hold.

The CO2 line’s air drain in the engine room was checked and found to be in order. The CO2 pipe aft of hold five was dismantled to check for any clogging but none was found. Again, compressed air was blown through but there was no air arriving at the exit end.  Further investigation found that in the CO2 room, the identification for the release valves for holds one, two, four and five were misidentified.

Only hold number three was correctly identified. As it turned out, the system was mis-identified upon initial installation from right to left instead of from left to right. Hence, only hold number three was correct, the others being in reverse order, and the error had not been caught.

 

Lessons Learned
Testing for the proper operation of the CO2 system is to be thoroughly conducted including physical check of outlets, not just cursory test or simply paper documentation for compliance.
Proper communication with personnel involved in the test must be established in order to confirm which valves are opened and that the release valve and lines match the labels on the information plate in the CO2 room.

Pointing the Finger at Careless Work Practices: Mars 201457

Three crew were in the process of overhauling a tank cleaning machine for one of the cargo tanks. At the end of the overhaul the cleaning machine was being repositioned in the hold using a tripod winch. As the inlet housing of the cleaning machine was being lowered in a controlled manner using the tripod winch, one of the crew inserted his fingers under the flange to retain the O ring in its grove as it kept slipping out of position. The inlet housing was approximately five cm off its final resting place when the winch, clamped on tripod leg, suddenly and unexpectedly moved. This caused the inlet housing flange to drop on the middle finger of the crewman’s right hand causing deep lacerations.

Report Findings

  • Inadequate engineering; the clamp holding the winch slipped on the tripod leg causing the suspended load to trap the crew’s finger.
  • Retaining the ‘O’ ring in the groove using fingers is incorrect practice. In such cases, it is good practice to use Loctite (or similar) to maintain the correct position of the ‘O’ ring in the groove of the flange.
  • Lack of thorough risk assessment prior to undertaking the job.

Weakened Wire Leaves Gangway Hanging: Mars 201458

When the vessel left port the accommodation ladder was left un-stowed in the horizontal position, hanging from the hoist wire, while crew were busy with departure tasks. Once away from berth, deck crew started the procedures for stowing the accommodation ladder in its seagoing position. Suddenly the hoist wire broke, letting the shore-end of the ladder fall. The ladder was now only attached to the ship by the main ramp. The vessel’s speed was reduced and the cargo crane was used to retrieve the ladder and place it on deck.

The wire was found to be in generally good condition and had been recently greased. Records and related photos indicate that inspection and maintenance intervals had been followed. The wire was almost two years old and was without indications of rust or defects along almost all of its length. However, it was observed that the point where the wire broke had more rust and less grease than elsewhere. After further investigation using the wire layout it was found that the break occurred at a point where access is difficult, thus rendering maintenance and greasing more arduous and less efficient. The wire at this particular point is continually exposed to sea/weather conditions yet can be less well maintained than the rest of the wire. Additionally, when the ladder is about to be stowed or deployed these same wire parts experience the maximum amount of tension.

Findings

  1. The wire was already wasted at the roller positions, which are always exposed to sea and weather. Given their location, these two points are hard to access for verification and maintenance.
  2. The ladder’s limit switch may have been bypassed during the operation.

Lessons Learned

  1. All vessels’ accommodation and pilot ladders should be checked for vulnerable points and wastage.
  2. Instructions should be given to vessels on how to treat the wires on these accommodation ladders.
  3. Crew should be given instructions on the use of limit switches and how they help protect the wire from excessive tension.
  4. The accommodation ladder manufacturer should be informed of the weak design.

Enclosed Spaces Claim Another Victim: Mars 201459

The vessel had berthed and commenced discharging, with a shore crane, a load of 72,000 metric tons of steaming coal. When requested by shore personnel to draw samples of the cargo, the duty officer instructed the crew member to do so by entering hold number six through the trunk that housed the Australian Ladder.

After about ten minutes the officer noticed that the crew member had not come up from the hold. When he went to the trunk opening he found the crew member had collapsed and was lying on the Australian Ladder just below the first landing about three metres below the main deck level. Immediately he mustered assistance; the crew member was brought on the main deck and attended to. The port ambulance brought the victim to the nearby hospital but he was declared dead on arrival.

Unfortunately, the atmosphere inside the trunking was only checked some 24 hours after the accident; Oxygen and carbon monoxide levels were found to be normal.

Investigation Findings

  • Enclosed Space Entry checks were not carried out.
  • The entry was made without the knowledge of the Master and chief officer.
  • The possibility of the carbon monoxide content being higher and/or oxygen content being lower than levels safe for human survival cannot be ruled out.
  • The entry was not monitored by the duty officer.
  • The crew member was on his first ship with only about 12 months sea time.
  • The trunking does not have ventilation ports along the entire height except the entry from the main deck by the booby hatch.

Editor’s note: Even though the victim was relatively new to the trade, it is reasonable to assume that even an experienced hand would have suffered the same fate in this instance due to the lack of procedural rigour. Masters and chief officers must be proactive in ensuring that these procedures are in place and are followed. As many readers may already know, SOLAS has been amended; enclosed space entry drills and training once every two months will become mandatory as of January 2015. Hopefully these additional measures will save lives.

Travelling Gantry Crane Inflicts Mortal Injuries: Mars 201460

Edited from official ATSB report MO-2013-010

The vessel was in port and routine ’travelling manoeuvres’ of the vessel’s gantry crane by a ship’s officer were being undertaken. The assistant electrician, probably standing near the top of the hatch access ladder, was caught and fatally crushed between the hatch lifting hook and the guide beam of the moving gantry crane.

At the time of the accident, this hatch lid was double stacked on another lid. The little clearance between the guide beam on the aft leg of the gantry crane and fittings on the hatch lids is even further reduced when they are double stacked. Each gantry crane was fitted with warning devices that operated automatically whenever the gantry crane
travelled along the length of the deck.

Warning lights were fitted on all four legs and a siren was fitted on each of the two forward legs. An emergency stop button was fitted to each leg and emergency stop pull wires were fitted along the braces that ran between the two legs.

Some of the findings and safety issues of the official report:

  • The assistant electrician did not comply with the requirements of the on board permit to work system. He did not gain the Master’s approval to work on deck during crane operations (an on board requirement and he did not ensure that the gantry crane driver was advised and that the gantry crane’s electrical power supply was isolated before he began working in the vicinity of the crane. The gantry crane ‘in motion’ warning light nearest to the assistant electrician’s location was not operating and the warning sirens were not audible from his location. As a result, he was not provided with either a visual or audible warning of the crane’s movement.
  • The on board familiarisation process did not ensure that new crew members were informed of the precautions required when working on deck while the gantry cranes were in operation.

Fatigue Wake-up Call for Shore-based Personnel: Mars 201461

Fatigue, and its deleterious effects on judgement, often feature in MARS reports. Usually, these reports concern on-board operations, but I have long been concerned about fatigue amongst shore-based employees of the marine industry. The marine transport industry works 24/7, 365 days a year, and the vessel’s shore-based support team have to keep the same pace as the ships. Flag State/Port State Inspectors, pilots, agents, chandlers, repair technicians, classification society and P & I surveyors all work long, gruelling hours. And to get to and from the job-site, they usually drive cars.

On one occasion as a marine inspector, I was driving home at the end of a very long work day and I fell asleep at the wheel. Fortunately, the motorway was equipped with lateral rumble strips and the noise and vibration woke me before I crashed. I am personally aware of two other serious incidents. In one, a cargo inspector departed the job-site in the early hours of the morning after a long day loading a bulk-carrier. He fell asleep at the wheel and drove into a ditch; fortunately without injuries.

In another incident, a classification society surveyor driving on a remote road in winter hit a patch of black ice. He skidded off the highway, down a steep slope, and crashed into rocks sustaining career-ending injuries.

I am concerned that the marine industry’s shore-based support staff are subject to the same dangers of fatigue as mariners, but without comparable awareness of the risks of fatigue.

Acknowledgement

Through the kind intermediary of The Nautical Institute we gratefully acknowledge sponsorship provided by:
American Bureau of Shipping, AR Brink & Associates, Britannia P&I Club, Cargill, Class NK, DNV, Gard, IHS Fairplay Safety at Sea International, International Institute of Marine Surveying, Lairdside Maritime Centre, London Offshore Consultants, MOL Tankship Management (Europe) Ltd, Noble Denton, North of England P&I Club, Sail Training International, Shipowners Club, The Marine Society and Sea Cadets, The Swedish Club, UK Hydrographic Office, West of England P&I Club

Submit a Mars Report

More reports are needed to keep the scheme interesting and informative. All reports are read only by the Mars coordinator and are treated in the strictest confidence. To submit a report please use the Mars report form and send it to mars@nautinst.org.