Everyone makes mistakes or has/sees near misses. By contributing reports to Mars, you can help others learn from your experiences. Read the latest reports from people who have already done so on SWZonline now.
Reports concerning navigation, cargo, engineering, ISM management, mooring, leadership, design, training or any other aspect of operations are welcome, as are alerts and reports even when there has been no incident. You can save a life, prevent injury and contribute to a more effective shipping community.
Reports will be carefully edited to preserve confidentiality or will remain unpublished if this is not possible. You can send them in through the Nautical Institute.
Mars Report No. 260
SWZ Maritime’s June issue, to appear 15 August, will feature a selection of the Mars reports published as Mars Report No. 260. Below the full report.
Cargo Block Opens: Mars 201430
During various cargo operations, two different manoeuvres have recently caused close calls where the cargo hook and associated equipment have fallen free. In one, the crane operator continued lowering even though the cargo block became snagged on a structural plate in the corner of the hatch coaming. This damaged the cargo block by opening the cheek plates and could have caused serious consequences.
In the other case, the crane operator swung the lift, which subsequently caused the cargo block to impact the cargo hold. This subjected the cargo block to excessive force and deformed the cheek plates.


Lessons Learned
- The crane operator should always watch the cargo lift and loose gears carefully, and should not make contact with the hatch or other structures.
- Stevedores should always watch cargo and loose gears carefully during slinging work and crane operation.
- As an added safety measure, the manufacturer recommended reinforcing the block with plates and bolts:

Improvisation Is a Slippery Slope: Mars 201431
Edited from official Australian Transportation Safety Report 301-MO-2013-009
The vessel was in port undergoing cargo operations. The stevedores stopped work for a shift change, and in the quiet period between the two shifts, one of the ship’s seamen decided to grease the hatch landing pads around the open cargo hold (Figure 1). The chief mate and the bosun were apparently not advised of the work and permission had not been obtained.
As the new shift of stevedores began to make their way into the cargo hold, the seaman was seen moving around the hatch coaming greasing the hatch lid landing pads. Suddenly, he slipped and fell, landing about 8.5 metres below on top of a container in the cargo hold (Figure 2). The seaman was admitted to the local hospital and provided with medical attention, being discharged and repatriated home afterward.
According to the ship’s crew, the greasing was normally carried out using an extended handle roller, allowing the work to be performed from the walkway. In this way, the crew are not exposed to the risk of falling from the hatch coamings.

Of Interest in this Accident
The seaman decided on the spur of the moment to grease the hatch pads. Choosing to grease the hatch landing pads during the period between stevedore shifts indicates that he may have identified the hazard of containers moving past his position. While he was showing initiative, the task was not appropriately planned, and he had not identified and mitigated the associated risks.
Furthermore, the fall hazard was magnified by the application of grease to areas of the hatch coaming that he would be walking over.
Good communication requires a flow of information in both directions of the management structure. This is particularly important on board a ship where a number of independent work groups can be engaged in multiple tasks.
Safety Message
This incident highlights the fact that people undertaking seemingly simple tasks with the best of intentions often overlook the planning and risk assessment stages. This is particularly the case when the task is undertaken when an unexpected and opportune moment arises to
complete the task.
Half an Anchor = Half Your Holding Power: Mars 201432
A two-year-old Panamax tanker was at anchor awaiting berth space to discharge a last parcel of cargo. The anchorage area was clear of obstructions and far from shore, the sea bed consisting of mud. During the night the weather conditions were good with a NE’ly winds force 3 and currents were not very strong. These conditions led us to believe that the anchor would hold well.
However, during watch handover the 2/O informed the relief that the vessel had dragged about half a cable to the SW. Subsequent monitoring of the vessel’s position confirmed a slow drag but luckily the pilot was due on shortly. As the anchor was lifted the bosun informed us that one fluke was missing. Everyone was amazed that a fluke from an anchor weighing 10,500kg had been broken in such benign conditions.

Once the anchor was on board everyone was very surprised to see the condition of the steel. Incredibly, we even found small pieces of rags trapped by some cement or plaster within the cast metal. A few weeks later, after the suspect metal had been analysed in a laboratory and a follow-up investigation done, we were informed that some anchors produced for the shipyard where our vessel was built had casting failures so bad that they were ‘corrected’ prior to final inspection and delivery to the shipyard.
Editor’s note: Even at a safe and benign anchorage a watchkeeper must always be vigilant and check the vessel’s position often. Also, use your anchor alarm if so equipped. Anchors and chains, even relatively new ones, can break at any time due to bad assembly or manufacturing faults.
Six-On/Six-Off Strikes Again: Mars 201433
Edited from official UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch report 4/2014
A small general cargo ship was in ballast and bound for Amsterdam, the Netherlands with a speed over ground (SOG) of approximately 7.5 knots. At 2355, the chief officer took over the bridge watch from the master, both sharing the watch-keeping duties using a 6-on, 6-off routine. At this time the vessel was on autopilot and heading 110°.
An AB was also on watch but he was told by the chief officer that he was not required on the bridge so he returned below. The vessel was rolling in the rough seas and the chief officer predominantly remained seated, monitoring the vessel’s progress against the navigational track on the radar. During his bridge watch, the chief officer completed some administrative tasks on the ship’s computer but did not plot the vessel’s position on the paper chart. At 0256, the vessel’s speed decreased rapidly as the vessel started to take the ground.
Soon after, the chief officer had put the main engine to full astern but the vessel was now stationary. The master was quickly on the bridge and moved the engine telegraph to stop. He noticed the GPS was indicating that the vessel’s position was close to the track on the display. He also noticed that the destination was waypoint 90, not waypoint 48 as he had expected. The master plotted the position displayed on the GPS receiver onto the paper chart and thus confirmed that the vessel was in very shallow water on Haisborough Sand.
In the incident report forwarded to the ship’s manager after the vessel was re-floated and had anchored, the master stated that the chief officer had experienced a problem keeping the vessel on course. He reportedly had changed from autopilot to hand-steering to emergency steering, but this did not solve the problem. The chief officer had called the master to the bridge, sent the chief engineer to check the steering system, sent seamen to open the ventilation flaps to allow the use of the bow thruster and to prepare both anchors for letting go. The master also stated that when he arrived on the bridge, he checked the steering but the vessel was drifting onto a shallow bank. The incident report also included the chief officer’s account, which accorded with the master’s description of events and a report from the AB on watch which stated that he had been on duty on the bridge between 0000 and 0400.
Subsequent investigations proved this story to be false.

Some of the Conclusions from the Official Report
- The vessel departed from the intended route because the waypoint selected as the destination in the GPS did not follow the sequence of waypoints detailed in the voyage plan.
- The chief officer did not notice that the vessel had deviated from the intended route because he relied solely on GPS and did not verify the course the vessel was following or plot the vessel’s position on a paper chart.
- The chief officer probably fell asleep for an extended period; he was alone on the bridge and the bridge watch alarm was switched off
- The circumstances of this accident together with the lack of integrity shown by the Master and chief officer in trying to hide the true sequence of events indicate a lack of a safety culture on board.
Editor’s note: The navigation practices on this vessel leave much to be desired and as indicated in the official report, the safety culture was demonstrably weak. But the fact that the vessel was staffed with only two watch-keepers using a 6-on 6-off routine was not the fault of the ship’s personnel. Following an accident or incident it may be tempting to try and re-work the facts in order to save face, but this is not a service to anyone, especially yourselves. The unsafe conditions that are at the root of every accident can only be discovered if you tell the truth. Most often, these unsafe conditions are not the fault of the vessel’s crew but ultimately stem from management and company leadership.
Costly Miscommunication: Mars 201434
Edited from Norwegian Club Casualty Letter No 94
Some twenty minutes after departure the cargo vessel’s main engine oil mist detector alarm sounded while the engine was at full ahead. The oil mist detector could not identify the cylinder unit causing the alarm and it was not connected to a shut down function. Hence, the engine crew tried to identify which unit was the problem while maintaining full ahead RPM.
Subsequently, the main engine low lube oil alarm sounded. After communicating these problems to the bridge, the Master considered it inconvenient for the vessel to stop and the vessel sailed for approximately two hours before they finally stopped the main engine. It was subsequently found that the main engine had suffered severe damage to the big end bearings and required renewal of the crank shaft; repairs that cost in the order of $1 million and left the vessel off-hire for more than forty days.
The same vessel suffered a similar occurrence a few years earlier and sister vessels have also suffered similar crank shaft failures.
Lessons Learned
From a technical point of view, the engine crew appears not to have taken the proper action when the oil mist detector alarm sounded or when the low pressure alarm sounded later as they maintained the engine RPM and load. There may well be specific reasons for their actions, but what would you do on your vessel in a similar situation?
- Would your engine crew be able to see the possible consequences of their actions?
- Do your engine crew communicate openly and with reasonable clarity for a non-technician on the bridge to appreciate the situation they are facing in the engine room?
- Does your chief engineer effectively communicate the criticality of his engine condition in order for you to balance this information with considerations for the safety of the vessel (location, currents, weather, traffic)?
- Do your Technical Managers inform you of relevant situations on other vessels in your fleet, or of sister vessels with problems that may well happen to you?
Water Mist Problems – Revisited: Mars 201435
A 1600 GT vessel built in 2006 was fitted with a Marioff high pressure water mist fire suppression system throughout the vessel. At a routine maintenance and test programme, 22 of the ‘wet pipe’ system sprinkler heads were found to be faulty and would not have operated had the system been activated in an emergency. A photograph of a typical head is shown, with an example of a contaminated spindle.

Investigations Identified
- The manufacturers had issued a bulletin in June 2012 identifying risks of contamination of the spindles and heads due to poor water quality, but this was not appropriately disseminated or shown on their web site. Water dosing and testing was recommended.
- The manufacturers had issued a second bulletin, also in June 2012, recommending that at least two heads from each section should be tested annually but again this was not appropriately disseminated or shown on their web site. Investigation showed that the manufacturers’ own technicians did not always follow the bulletin, often only testing the pressure drop on the system by using a drain valve rather than testing a head, or removing heads ashore for testing (this would not always identify failures as the heads would be disturbed as part of removal et cetera).
- The manufacturers had issued a third bulletin in May 2013 recommending increasing the standby water pressure from 25 to 40 bar to ensure that the spindles were operated when the system operated. Again this appears to have not been appropriately disseminated.
- Certain flag authorities had issued information highlighting other failures, up to 50%, found on water extinguishing systems and the need for regular testing/maintenance.
- IMO MSC.1/Circ.1432 does provide some guidance on this issue.
- It is considered that there is a high risk that the system will not work as required in an emergency unless all sprinkler systems, including the water within the system, is correctly maintained and tested.
Editor’s note: Mars 201414 was also on the topic of inoperable water mist suppression systems, although in that report the problem was due to many systems having been found with their main water supply valve closed.
Acknowledgement
Through the kind intermediary of The Nautical Institute we gratefully acknowledge sponsorship provided by:
American Bureau of Shipping, AR Brink & Associates, Britannia P&I Club, Cargill, Class NK, DNV, Gard, IHS Fairplay Safety at Sea International, International Institute of Marine Surveying, Lairdside Maritime Centre, London Offshore Consultants, MOL Tankship Management (Europe) Ltd, Noble Denton, North of England P&I Club, Sail Training International, Shipowners Club, The Marine Society and Sea Cadets, The Swedish Club, UK Hydrographic Office, West of England P&I Club
Submit a Mars Report
More reports are needed to keep the scheme interesting and informative. All reports are read only by the Mars coordinator and are treated in the strictest confidence. To submit a report please use the Mars report form and send it to mars@nautinst.org.







