(MARS 201865) A collision between a tug boat and bulk carrier caused the tug to sink. Eighteen crew were unable to get out of the tug and drowned.
Edited from the official Hong Kong SAR Marine Department Marine Accident Investigation Section
A loaded bulk carrier was inbound to its destination port with a bridge team consisting of the master, an OOW, a helmsman and two pilots. There was a light westerly breeze and a smooth sea with visibility at about 2 nm and a light drizzle.
Pilot A had the con. Pilot B reported to Pilot A that he had observed a radar target fine on the starboard bow at a range of about 2.5 nm. The target was a seagoing tug on a course of about 090° and was making near 10 kt. The bulk carrier was heading 260° at about 13.5 kt.
A few minutes later, pilot B tried to attract the attention of the tug by flashing the Aldis lamp in its direction. The tug was still very fine on the starboard bow and now at a range of about 1.6nm, showing a red sidelight. The pilots expected the tug to alter course to starboard, but instead it maintained course and speed.
VTC Contacts Tug
Shortly after this, pilot A asked pilot B to contact the vessel traffic centre (VTC) to provide information on the target and to advise the tug that the two vessels should pass port to port to avoid collision. VTC called the tug and instructed them to take action to avoid collision.
Although the tug responded, it was impossible to understand the response. A few minutes later pilot A instructed the helmsman to alter course slowly to starboard to 265° in order to enter the deep water channel with the CP1 buoy close on the starboard side.
Tug Rapidly Alters Course
A few minutes later, the tug was very fine on the port bow of the bulk carrier and at a range of about 0.5 nm. Pilot A gave a helm order of starboard 10 with a view to keeping the tug on the port bow and giving it as much room as possible to pass on the port side. Pilot B gave one short blast on the whistle.
Within seconds, the tug was observed to alter course rapidly to port. Pilot A ordered the helmsman to put the wheel to starboard 20, and followed by hard to starboard. Pilot B sounded five short and rapid blasts on the whistle.
As the tug continued to alter its course to port and its masthead lights opened more widely. Pilot B again sounded five short and rapid blasts on the whistle. Pilot A then gave a port 10 helm order in order to the reduce rate of turn of the bulk carrier to starboard and to allow the tug to pass clear ahead.
Heavy Collision Impact
Pilot A then gave a helm order of starboard 10, but the bow of the bulk carrier struck the starboard quarter of the tug. The collision impact was heavy and the bulk carrier was brought to a stop.
Shortly after the collision, the tug listed to starboard and sank. Seven persons were rescued from the tug, but eighteen crew were trapped and drowned inside the vessel.

Lessons Learned
- Never make small course alterations when faced with an ambiguous meeting or crossing situation.
- Make your intentions known by using a large course alteration, preferably to starboard as per the collision regulations.
- When in doubt, slow down.
MARS Reports
This is one of the October MARS Reports that are part of Report Number 312. A selection of this Report has also been published in SWZ|Maritime’s November issue.
Acknowledgement
Through the kind intermediary of The Nautical Institute we gratefully acknowledge sponsorship provided by:
American Bureau of Shipping, AR Brink & Associates, Britannia P&I Club, Cargill, Class NK, DNV, Gard, IHS Fairplay Safety at Sea International, International Institute of Marine Surveying, Lairdside Maritime Centre, London Offshore Consultants, MOL Tankship Management (Europe) Ltd, Noble Denton, North of England P&I Club, Sail Training International, Shipowners Club, The Marine Society and Sea Cadets, The Swedish Club, UK Hydrographic Office, West of England P&I Club
Submit a Mars Report
More reports are needed to keep the scheme interesting and informative. All reports are read only by the Mars coordinator and are treated in the strictest confidence. To submit a report, please use the Mars report form and send it to mars@nautinst.org.







